Rum Old Fashioned

Rum Old Fashioned cocktail in an old-fashioned glass

Stir with ice, strain and serve over a large ice cube in an old-fashioned glass. Garnish with an orange twist.

We found this recipe on It takes the drink in a different direction from the traditional rum old-fashioned, the Corn 'N' Oil. Here we have the aroma of orange from the garnish, the richness of the Demerara syrup and the faint but very pleasant aftertaste of Christmas cookie spice from the allspice dram. The original recipe simply calls for dark rum but that covers a wide range of rums, many of them best used for mixing. We have tried both Plantation XO 20th Anniversary and Plantation Barbados 5 year Rum with success.